Foreign investment in Indonesia is commonly conducted through the establishment of a Foreign Investment Limited Liability Company (Perseroan Terbatas Penanaman Modal Asing or “PT PMA”), with foreign investors participating as shareholders. In carrying out its business activities, the management of the company’s funds and assets falls under the responsibility of the Board of Directors, in accordance with its authority and applicable laws and regulations.
However, the risk of corporate fund misappropriation may arise when directors or affiliated parties use the company’s assets and funds for personal interests or the benefit of another company without proper approval or disclosure. Such circumstances may cause losses to the company and trigger disputes among foreign investors, directors, and other shareholders.
In these situations, foreign investors need to understand their legal rights to hold the parties involved accountable, including determining the appropriate dispute resolution mechanism based on the company’s Articles of Association, Shareholders Agreement (SHA), and applicable Indonesian laws and regulations.
Misuse of Corporate Funds and Related-Party Transactions
In a PT PMA, the company’s funds and assets must be used for the benefit of the company and its business activities. Misuse may occur, for example, when directors use company funds to provide loans to affiliated companies, finance personal interests, or conduct transactions without obtaining the required approval.
Related-party transactions also require particular attention. Although such transactions are not necessarily prohibited, their implementation must take into account the company’s interests, the authority of its corporate organs, and the applicable disclosure and approval requirements.
For example, a PT PMA has a foreign investor as one of its shareholders. In the course of its business operations, the director uses company funds to provide a loan to another company owned by a family member without disclosing the transaction to the shareholders or obtaining the required approval. If the transaction causes losses to the company, the director’s actions may raise issues concerning their liability and responsibilities in managing the company.
Foreign Shareholders’ Rights and Directors’ Liability
Under Law No. 40 of 2007 concerning Limited Liability Companies, as amended (the “Company Law”), the Board of Directors is responsible for managing the company in its best interests and in accordance with its purposes and objectives. Article 97 stipulates that each member of the Board of Directors must perform their duties in good faith and with full responsibility.
If a director is proven to have committed a fault or negligence in carrying out their duties, resulting in losses to the company, the relevant director may be held personally liable in accordance with Article 97 of the Company Law.
Foreign investors, in their capacity as shareholders, also have several legal remedies available to them, including:
- Derivative Action: Under Article 97 paragraph (6) of the Company Law, shareholders representing at least one-tenth of the total shares with voting rights may file a lawsuit against members of the Board of Directors before the court on behalf of the company if the directors’ actions have caused losses to the company.
- Personal Shareholder Lawsuit: Under Article 61, a shareholder may file a lawsuit against the company if they suffer losses as a result of company actions deemed unfair and without reasonable grounds, arising from resolutions of the General Meeting of Shareholders, the Board of Directors, or the Board of Commissioners.
- Application for a Company Examination: Under Article 138, shareholders who meet the applicable requirements may apply for an examination of the company if there are reasonable suspicions that the company has suffered losses due to actions taken by the company, the Board of Directors, or the Board of Commissioners.
Accordingly, foreign investors may not only seek protection for their personal interests as shareholders but may also, under certain circumstances, take legal action to protect the interests of the company.
Determining the Dispute Resolution Mechanism
In a PT PMA involving foreign investors, the appropriate dispute resolution mechanism must first be determined by reviewing the company’s internal regulations and the agreements binding upon the relevant parties. Such provisions are generally set out in the company’s Articles of Association and/or the Shareholders Agreement (SHA), which regulate shareholders’ rights and obligations as well as the procedures for resolving disputes in the event of a conflict.
Therefore, the parties cannot unilaterally determine the dispute resolution mechanism without taking into account the provisions previously agreed upon and applicable within the company. Where the Articles of Association or SHA stipulates specific procedures, such as settlement through deliberation, negotiation, mediation, arbitration, or court proceedings, those provisions should serve as the basis for determining the appropriate legal steps.
For example, if the parties have agreed to resolve disputes through international arbitration, the dispute resolution process must follow the mechanism and rules of the selected arbitration institution. Conversely, if the parties have agreed to resolve disputes through an arbitration institution in Indonesia, such as the Indonesian National Arbitration Board (Badan Arbitrase Nasional Indonesia or “BANI”), the proceedings must also be conducted in accordance with the rules and procedures of that institution.
Conclusion
Misuse of corporate funds and non-transparent related-party transactions may create legal risks and cause losses to a PT PMA. Therefore, foreign investors need to understand their rights as shareholders, ensure that the company is managed in accordance with applicable legal requirements, and determine the appropriate legal steps and dispute resolution mechanisms based on the Articles of Association, SHA, and applicable Indonesian laws and regulations.
In addressing these matters, Schinder Law Firm provides legal consultation and assistance to foreign investors and PT PMAs in Indonesia, including reviewing corporate documents, assessing directors’ liability, protecting shareholders’ rights, and developing dispute resolution strategies. With appropriate legal guidance, investors can take measured steps to protect their investment interests while ensuring the company’s compliance with Indonesian law.
Please contact Schinder Law Firm at info@schinderlawfirm.com for further consultation.
Author:
Budhi Satya Makmur